Search Site:

 19 April 2015

How The Anti-Vaccine Movement Is Funded

April 18th, 2015

Of all the modern anti-science movements out there, few are more dangerous or harmful than the anti-vaccine movement. Yes, it has killed people. It will continue to kill people. It has also resulted in huge amounts of money and resources being devoted to combating public health problems that should have (and in some cases were) eliminated years ago.

One thing that is very noteworthy about the movement is just how well funded it seems to be.  Obviously some of the funding comes from the fact that it often is a business and money is invested directly to make a return.  Many of the dishonest doctors who have spoken out against vaccines do so to make money directly.  In such cases, it is a self-funded enterprise, promoted like any other venture and funded by the sales of books, lecture tickets and various “detoxification” products and a like.

The alternative medicine world is very lucrative and has a great deal of interest in the anti-vaccine movement.  Many of the promoters are either directly or indirectly profiting from it.  Some may simply be pushing the message of homeopathy or other areas of quackery and the message against vaccines is simply part and parcel of the medical philosophy they choose to sell.

There are also true “grass roots” activists out there (read idiots).  They work on their own time and may even contribute their own money to efforts to stop the progress of vaccines in combating infectious disease.  However, these efforts are usually very amateurish in their style.

A few organizations stand out, however, as having a very professional and credible image which has clearly come from a well-funded effort targeted directly at discrediting vaccines.  Chief among them is the National Vaccine Information Center.  It is a non-profit that has paid for billboards and media campaigns against vaccines and runs one of the most visited websites on the topic.  What makes it stand out is how professional and well managed the effort seems to be.  The website is well designed and looks credible.  The information provided is also deceptively well worded.  They stay away from the more outlandish claims of things like chemtrails and Illuminati plots, but drive home a seemingly plausible story of deaths and injuries from vaccines.

Like many such efforts, they are hiding behind the false notion of “personal choice” in a matter which really only has one rational choice.  There is no valid scientific reason to oppose vaccines (unless you just hate humans and love pathogens.)   But the slick campaign and message makes it clear that there are deep pockets behind the effort.

Similar efforts have funded everything from advertisements in magazines to “independent” documentary movies on the topic.

It turns out that there are, in fact, some very wealthy individuals who are behind this. Their motive seems to be a genuine belief that vaccines cause harm. Clearly, you can be rich and still very stupid.

This video from CNN just scratches the surface of the issue:


(click here if your browser does not support embedded video)Unfortunately, it will be hard to take down these well-funded foundations. If these were rich individuals who were making money in a certain business sector, the
logical thing to do would be to destroy their companies through boycotts. Yet these foundations seem to be mostly founded by individuals with a lot of acquired wealth, which is not going anywhere. The Dwoskins do make money from a current property management group, but it would be hard to boycott such a company, since they have a limited number of clients, many of whom are locked into leases. Barry Segal is retired and just has a lot of money burning a hole in his pocket so little can be done there.

None the less, it is important not to become completely discouraged. This is not a grass-roots movement. It’s both a business sector and a campaign by some very twisted rich people. That should be all the more reason to get the message out and fight back.  Just getting out that message alone can do much to undermine the image the movement has worked to craft.

Posted in Bad Science, Quackery

A wonderful and inspirational Facebook page

April 1st, 2015

A happy April first to all!

As I promised, I have not abandoned this blog.  After a hiatus, I will be back in the near future with many more posts.

In the mean time, I suggest this Facebook Page, where you can gain your share of daily wisdom and inspiration on things like natural health and organics!

Posted in Announcements, Humor, Links, Website

No, the site is not dead. Yes, there will be new content

March 9th, 2015

Just a quick announcement:  Many have pointed out that new content for this site has been a bit lacking recently.  I totally understand this and the concern that the twilight of Depleted Cranium might be looming.   However, I have every intent of keeping up the blog.

Right now, I have a number of personal and professional obligations converging.  As a result, I will be on more or less of a hiatus from new posts until April.

I realize that blogs thrive on new content and taking some time off will likely mean diminished traffic and page ranks.  Unfortunately, I just have too much going on.
Steve Packard

Posted in Announcements, personal, Website

The Best Late Night Bit Ever (on Vaccines)

February 28th, 2015

Rarely do I create a post just to show off a video, much less a comedy video from a late night television show.  However, this bit from Jimmy Kimmel Live is great.  It’s about vaccines and it’s funny and on point.

I think my favorite thing about this is that the message to vaccinate kids and opposition to the anti-vaccine movement is making such a strong showing in the mainstream media.  While late night talk shows aren’t exactly the best place to get information, they are a good reflection on cultural trends.  Putting out the pro-vaccine message on science blogs and even in the news media is great and should be encouraged.  However, it is a huge step when it starts to enter more of our culture and media.

Ridicule is also a important weapon in opposing anti-science rhetoric and quackery.  There is nothing wrong with calling an idea stupid when it is, in fact, stupid, and sometimes putting it in its place with appropriate ridicule is the best way of driving the point home.  There’s also good reason why humor is used in so many advertisements.  Humor gets people’s attention and helps make the message memorable.

Here’s the clip from Jimmy Kimmel Live.  It’s fantastic.

(Click here if your browser does not support embedded video)

Posted in Bad Science, Culture, Good Science, Humor

As Predicted, Jessica Ainscough Has Died Of Her Untreated Cancer

February 27th, 2015



I take no pleasure in saying this.  However, it has come to my attention that Jessica Ainscough, the woman who I predicted would die of untreated cancer has passed away.

She was 30 years.  She spent seven of those years with a slowly progressing cancer that would ultimately kill her.

It was 2012 when I predicted this outcome, noting that the slow moving cancer would likely take a few more years to kill her.  It took about three.   To be perfectly honest, that’s roughly what I had expected, based on what doctors had told me and some research on the progression of the condition.

It is surely a sad day for her friends and family.  It’s terrible to lose a life at such an age, especially when it could have been prevented.  However, I believe this needs to be publicized and used as an example of how deadly cancer quackery can be.  She spent much of her life encouraging others to go down the path of fake treatments and quackery.  The ultimate result should be proof to any others who face the difficult decision of how to treat their cancer.

More info can be found here.

Posted in Announcements, Bad Science, Quackery

Congratulations Anti-Vaxers, You Killed a Baby!

February 24th, 2015

Measles is a very contagious disease.  It’s usually something that people get over, without permanent damage, although complications are not all that uncommon.  Deaths are relatively rare, but they do happen.   At one time, a country like the United States would expect to experience a few dozen deaths from measles, mostly in children, per year.

That began to change when an effective vaccine was developed in 1968.  It took some time for the vaccine to proliferate across the industrial world, and measles outbreaks continued into the 1980′s.  However by the late 1990′s, measles had become an uncommon condition in most of the developed world.  It did not go away completely, but by the turn of the 21st century, most public health officials considered measles to be a problem of the past and efforts on further eradication focused on third world countries, where low vaccine rates allowed it to flourish.

CanadameaslesThat began to change, however, as more parents started to buy into the propaganda of an increasingly well funded and vocal anti-vaccine movement.  It started with claims that vaccine caused autism.  Then they began to talk about all manner of “vaccine injury,” which, in most cases, was a complete fabrication.  Yet the fear of vaccines took hold enough for many parents to leave their children unvaccinated.  Many became so sold on the idea they would work to spread the message to others.

What happened is exactly what you would expect to happen.  A disease as contagious as measles once again had a population capable of sustaining an outbreak and that’s what happened.  In the United States, a single incident, where a number of persons were exposed in Disneyland resulted in a multi-state outbreak that has now spread to several states.  The numbers keep climbing and are now well over one hundred and fifty, although its likely that far more have not been reported.

Measels2Of course, the US is not alone.  Similar outbreaks and increases in rate of measles have swept the industrial world.  Canada, the United Kingdom and Germany have also faced the prospect of decreasing vaccine rates leading to measles outbreaks.  Other outbreaks have happened in the Netherlands, New Zealand, Italy, Singapore and New Zealand.

In many places, vaccine refusal has just begun to reach the critical number necessary for full scale outbreaks to be sustained in the population.  This has resulted in some very dramatic upticks in the rate of the diseases.  For example, Turkey reported 7,132 cases in 2014, up from 700 in 2013.  In New Zealand, 2014 saw 281 cases reported, while only 8 cases had been reported in 2013.

Up until now, no lives had been lost to the outbreaks.  There are a few reasons for this.  One is that vaccines are still reasonably common and therefore, the outbreaks have been small compared to those of decades ago.  Another reason is that, when someone gets measles, every effort is made to prevent them from dying.

Serious complications, complications that could even cause death, are not uncommon from measles.  But when they do happen, the health system springs into action and usually manages to save the lives of those infected.  For example, about 15% of those infected in the recent US outbreak ended up in the hospital.  When this happens, they are monitored, fluids and fever reducers are given, antibiotics are called for if there are secondary infections and doctors monitor their recovery.  Some will develop pneumonia and require breathing assistance, such as supplemental oxygen.  Vitamin A may be given by IV, as there is some evidence of decreased mortality when high vitamin A levels are maintained.

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Bad Science, Quackery

Why do a few doctors come out against vaccines?

February 7th, 2015

Vaccines represent one of the greatest achievements in public health.  They have saved millions of lives and have the ability to completely eradicate some infectious diseases.  They’re also extremely safe.  Serious reactions to vaccines are extremely rare and deaths are even more rare.  They certainly do not suppress the immune system, make people less healthy or cause autism.

The anti-vaccine movement is a false controversy, predicated on ignorance and lies.  It exploits fallacies, like the belief that “natural” things are always good or that any foreign substance must be harmful to the body, if it is put there by human intervention.  It is also based on fear, especially the natural instinct of parents to protect their children and not harm them.  Considering the number of websites and organizations that support these lies, it’s not surprising that many people have fallen for it.

The vast majority of those who run these organizations and campaign against vaccines have no medical or scientific background at all.  Some are garden variety conspiracy theorists.  Others are celebrities, who became famous because they posed in men’s magazines or for acting or music.  They seem to believe that its their duty to use their fame to promote something that they believe, even despite their lack of actual authority on the matter.

The overwhelming majority of competent doctors and scientists in the field will tell you that vaccines are very safe and quite effective.  Even doctors whose field is not immunology generally have enough basic training in general medicine and biology to understand this undeniable fact.  Those who are well versed in the real data, whether they are doctors, public health officials or just science advocates are in almost universal agreement in support of vaccines.


While it isn’t surprising that most doctors and experts do support vaccines, it is a little surprising that there are some who do not.  They are few and far between.  In fact, there seem to be only a handful of them worldwide, but they do exist.

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Bad Science, Quackery

29 Years Since The Challenger Exploded, One of My Earliest Memories

January 28th, 2015

Space flight is dangerous.  Taking a rocket into orbit means sitting on a controlled explosion happening under an enormous tank of fuel and oxidizer.  Rocket engines are under such tremendous forces, they push engineering to its limits.  Once one arrives in space, the spacecraft must protect occupants from one of the harshest environments imaginable.  Then, upon return, the rapid reentry to the atmosphere subjects the craft to enormous heat and pressure.  Every part of a space mission is dangerous.

It is more dangerous when politics and a desire for good publicity and scheduling gets in the way of more important concerns over safety and engineering.   This is what happened to the Challenger.  It was the first American space mission to result in causalities (although astronauts had died before in practice sessions and dry runs, such as Apollo 1).  It was the worst loss of life in a single space mission up to that time.  It would be tied by the 2003 breakup of the shuttle Columbia.

The accident put a temporary halt to the US space program and resulted in numerous safety improvements.  Unfortunately, these improvements were not enough to stop another tragedy from happening with the Space Shuttle.  While the Shuttle proved to be one of he most capable craft for low earth orbit, with unique capabilities, like the capacity to retrieve satellites from orbit, it also has some other, more dubious, distinctions.  More lives have been lost in the Space Shuttle than any other spacecraft.  It has a LOVC (loss of vehicle and crew) rate of greater than one percent, for all launches.

For me, the Challenger incident has other significance.  I was three years old at the time if happened.  It is one of my earliest distinct memories and the earliest memory I can pin directly to an event.

My memories are vague, but I do remember a few things.  My mother worked with a man whose television was not working on that day.  He came over to my home to watch the TV coverage.  He and my father were glued to the set all afternoon and evening.  I was upset because I wanted to watch Mister Roger’s neighborhood and we only had the one television.

My parents watched ABC news.  It’s amazing but these videos actually jar distinct memories for me.

Posted in History, media, personal, Space

The Truth About Aluminum Toxicity

January 15th, 2015

One of the things that I have been hearing a lot of recently is that vaccines are dangerous because they contain aluminum.  Similarly, various chemtrail conspiracy theorists frequently cite aluminum as being one of the dangerous ingredients in their imaginary chemical discharges.  They’re not alone.  Others have said that children’s medicines contain dangerous amounts of aluminum which could cause everything from autism and dementia.  It’s strange to see this common material, which we encounter daily becoming something so many are afraid of.

Presented here is some information on what kind of concerns aluminum and it’s most fundamental compounds present.  Spoiler: It’s pretty benign stuff and for most people there’s no concern at all about toxicity.

Sorry, but you have been exposed to aluminum, possibly a lot of it:

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Bad Science, Conspiracy Theories, Quackery

Chlorine Dioxide: A Horrific Treatment for Autism

January 11th, 2015

I have written before about a product being sold as Miracle Mineral Supplement.  It claims to cure everything from cancer to malaria, but is actually one of the most dangerous quack products out there.

Miracle Mineral Supplement is actually sodium chlorite, a toxic and reactive compound.  The instructions for Miracle Mineral Supplement tell users to “activate” the product by combining it with citric acid.  The result is a chemical reaction which produces chlorine dioxide.  Chlorine dioxide is a gas, although it can dissolve into water.  It is not something you would ever want to be exposed to in any quantity.  It is a powerful oxidizer and bleaching agent.  The most common use of chlorine dioxide is in the paper industry, where it is used to bleach wood pulp.  It also is used for fumigation and disinfection purposes.

Chlorine dioxide is very toxic and in high doses it could easily be fatal.  In low doses, like those which might be produced from the Miracle Mineral Supplement product, it is not likely to be fatal, but it can be highly irritating to the skin, the respiratory tract and the eyes.  It is, after all, bleach.  It’s not quite the same as household chlorine bleach (that is sodium hypochlorite) but it is a bleaching agent – one more powerful than the bleach used for household cleaning or whitening laundry.

Despite this, some people still swear by the stuff and use it at their own peril.

One of the most horrific uses, the treatment of autism:

It is one thing to use this nasty chemical on oneself, but it is being pushed as a treatment for autism and is being used primarily on children by believers.   Autism is a neurological condition that exists because of developmental issues that arise before birth, even if it is not obvious until some time later.   There is no cure for autism, as such. However, intensive therapy, special education and social groups can result in major improvements in the prognosis for many autistic children, especially those who do not have a severe case of autism.

Chlorine dioxide certainly has no benefit to autistic children.  It is hard to imagine anything more harmful to a child with social developmental problems than to subject them to the painful and damaging effects of an oxidizer.  If nothing else, it can easily harm the natural inclination to see parents as protective and trusted.

Yet that is exactly what some are pushing.  The website pushes a book and is run by a group of quacks who actively encourage the use of chlorine dioxide to treat autism.  The side claims autism is “avoidable, treatable and curable” and recommends chlorine dioxide, which it calls “an inexpensive, broad spectrum, gentle, anti-pathogenic.”

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Bad Science, Not Even Wrong, Quackery