This is not exactly a recent news story, but as it didn’t get much attention in the media, I only recently found out about the death of Professor Rustum Roy. Dr. Roy died on August 24 at the age of 86.
Rustum Roy was a professor of material sciences who had earned his PhD in ceramics in 1948. He was legitimately an educated and accomplished scientist in this area and nobody can take this away from him. However, beginning in the 1960’s, Roy also became heavily involved in alternative sciences, especially alternative medicine. In recent years, Rustum Roy had been a mainstay of homeopathy and other generally rejected areas of medicine.
Although trained in materials sciences, he had no background to speak of in medicine. Despite this, most of his recent activities focused in this area. He also had been active in promoting religious-based science. He founded the organization “Whole Person Healing” which promotes homeopathy and other alternative medicine.
He had also lent his name to other areas of questionable science such as claims of “water fuel” and “water burning.”
One of the things that always bothered me a great deal about Roy’s arguments were that they were generally an appeal to authority. Roy argued often about “water memory” and the idea that water molecules could have structure that would somehow transfer information to human cells and thus effect health. Offering no empirical evidence, he generally resorted to simply pointing out that he was a professor and had a PhD in materials sciences. Of course, this is a complete straw-man, especially considering that his area of formal training wasn’t related to biology or medicine.
Rustum Roy had been discussed on this site on several occasions.
I should finally say that despite the fact that I believe Rustum Roy did a lot more harm than good in the later part of his life and that his views on things like homeopathy were far out in left field, I certainly never wished the man death. It has always been my impression of Rustum Roy that he was not so much a scamster as genuinely self-deluded into his own unsupported beliefs. That said, we do have one less prominent homeopath in the world.
While living t0 86 is definitely a full life, it’s hardly an exceptionally old age, considering that there are close to one hundred thousand persons of 100 years of age or older in the United States. Thus, it would seem that the claims that homeopathy can be used to cure nearly all ailments and thereby achieve exceptional longevity are, once again, proven wrong.