Atheist Billboard “Controversal” in New York City

December 19th, 2010
submit to reddit Share

In case you are not aware of this story, a billboard was recently erected by the American Atheists at the entrance to the Lincoln Tunnel in New York City. The billboard can be seen bellow:

As one might expect, the billboard has been very controversial, leading to a second billboard to be put up on the other side of the tunnel by the Catholic League. Some have complained that the billboard attempts to kill the spirit of Christmas or see it as insulting or offensive. The response billboard, which has a similar imagery but says “You know it’s true” has drawn less criticism.

Via the National Post:

Advent has just started, but the war over Christmas is already underway, and for the most part, it appears that Christmas is winning.

In New York, it’s a battle of billboards; in Philadelphia, it’s battle over a word. Retailers, meanwhile are increasingly embracing Christmas in their advertising and promotions.

In New York, the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights has sponsored a Christmas billboard outside the Lincoln Tunnel in response to a Christmas-debunking billboard sponsored by American Atheists.

The battling billboards are posted on opposite sides of the Lincoln Tunnel. The Catholic League’s billboard is on the New York side. The American Atheists billboard is on the New Jersey side.

The Catholic League-sponsored billboard features a nativity scene and the words: You Know It’s Real: This Season Celebrate Jesus. The American Atheists-sponsored billboard reads: You know it’s a myth. This season, celebrate reason!

In this case I can’t help but think that the message by the American Atheists isn’t really a great idea. The billboard may say to “celebrate reason” but it’s likely that some will see it as just being anti-Christmas. Regardless of what anyone believes, you are not going to win any friends if you look like you are in any way planning on opposing a day off from work or an excuse to eat drink and be merry.

The early Christians seemed to understand this. Christmas is really nothing more than a new kind of mythology attached to the existing pagan solstice festivals. Societies may be persuaded to give up their gods, but to give up their parties is quite another thing.

Therefore, I’d propose that the message atheists should be spreading this holiday season is one that embraces the secular traditions we’ve all come to associate with Christmas while dismissing the religious ones. After all, Halloween was once also a religious holiday, and you don’t have to believe in spirits and daemons to wear costumes and hand out candy.

A few ideas I had for a billboard…


This entry was posted on Sunday, December 19th, 2010 at 5:32 pm and is filed under Culture, Misc, Politics, religion. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
View blog reactions



56 Responses to “Atheist Billboard “Controversal” in New York City”

Pages: « 1 [2] Show All

  1. 51
    ErBearPsych Says:

            Calli Arcale said:

    (Hence, I have serious problems with faith healers, plural marriage, child marriage, and anyone who still practices animal sacrifice. But if someone believes the world was created by Ahuru Mazda, that’s fine by me. It’s not really that important.)

    Okay, the curiosity is getting to me. What’s the logic behind the problems with plural marriage?

            Juums said:

    It’s doubly a pity that the atheists of NYC feel obliged to insinuate that it is impossible to be both religious and a believer in the reason of the Enlightenment. For, try as they might to say otherwise, the two are not mutually exclusive.

    Based on everything I’ve ever been taught, you cannot fully practice the reasoning of the Enlightenment and be a religious believer at the same time. There are some things that must be taken “on faith.” They cannot be proven, and yet they are believed. This is contrary to logic. You can embrace rationality in all other aspects of your life, but the dogma of whatever organized religion you practice must be accepted without proof, this is the essence of faith.


    Quote Comment
  2. 52
    Matte Says:

    Yea, I would also like to know what is wrong with polygamy! I mean if some nut head can put up with more than one wife, then good on him (I say him as it is usually a patriarichal system)…

    @Ben
    get laid (!), your future wife/partner will thank you for it…
    Abstinence is quite perverse and one of the most deviant forms of self denial I can think of, ask any Freudian inclined psychiatrist/psychologist.


    Quote Comment
  3. 53
    Anon Says:

            Matte said:

    Yea, I would also like to know what is wrong with polygamy! I mean if some nut head can put up with more than one wife, then good on him (I say him as it is usually a patriarichal system)…

    The problem with polygamy is that if it were common you’d end up with a lot of single men unable to find a mate which tends to cause social problems (i.e. crime).


    Quote Comment
  4. 54
    Matthew Says:

            Anon said:

    The problem with polygamy is that if it were common you’d end up with a lot of single men unable to find a mate which tends to cause social problems (i.e. crime).

    IIRC, Indonesia’s polygamy rate is ~4% (mentioned in class by a prof about 5 years ago). It’s generally confined to the rich/powerful – they need to support multiple wives and minor children, and that takes cash.


    Quote Comment
  5. 55
    Matte Says:

            Anon said:

    The problem with polygamy is that if it were common you’d end up with a lot of single men unable to find a mate which tends to cause social problems (i.e. crime).

    Nha, polygamy would never catch on as it could not possibly work for reasonable human beings.


    Quote Comment
  6. 56
    DV82XL Says:

    Polygamy and polyandry are social arrangements that cultures adopt due to economic circumstance. They are not driven by a simple desire for multiple sexual partners. The few that would chose to live in these marriages in a modern Western situation would be too few to make a real difference.


    Quote Comment

Pages: « 1 [2] Show All

Leave a Reply

Current month ye@r day *

Please copy the string tUuZsK to the field below:

Protected by WP Anti Spam